
Caterpillar CAT, Hershey HSY, Honeywell Aerospace HONY/HONA, Polaris PII...
Analysis of Selected Stocks: Hershey, Honeywell, Rollins, Polaris, and Caterpillar
The speaker critically evaluates several stocks, warning of overvalued prices in a high-interest-rate environment and potential economic cycles.
Hershey (HSY)- Past Hype: Benefited from the growth mania of the early 2020s, peaking in 2022.
- Current Valuation: P/E ratio of 20, dividend yield of 3%. Total return (~5-6%) only slightly above 10-year Treasury yields.
- Conclusion: Solid business with 4-5% growth, but fairly to overvalued. Not a bargain.
- Business Figures: 2% growth, solid adjusted EBIT, free cash flow of around $1 billion.
- Valuation: P/E ratio of 24, free cash flow yield of 4%.
- Risk: Highly cyclical. A recession could lead to a 50% drop in share price.
- Conclusion: Good company, but high cyclical risk at current valuation.
- Price Decline: Stock has fallen significantly, but P/E ratio is still 30 (previously 40).
- Valuation: Fairly valued for its quality, but still expensive.
- Conclusion: Not a buy at this price level.
- Business: Off-road vehicles, boats, RVs. Revenue and earnings still growing.
- Valuation: Market cap of $3.5 billion, but high debt and leverage.
- Risk: The sector is extremely cyclical and vulnerable to economic downturns. Weak consumers could hurt sales.
- Conclusion: High risk, few competitive advantages.
- Current Situation: P/E ratio of 24, strong revenue growth from energy supply (data centers), mining, and construction.
- Earnings: 2023/2024 ~$11-12 billion in profit.
- Risk: Extremely cyclical. In a downturn (e.g., recession), earnings could collapse to $2 billion, implying a P/E ratio of >100. Market cap could fall below $100 billion.
- Conclusion: Currently a speculative stock. Over the cycle, the average P/E ratio is 35. Only suitable for speculative investors.
The speaker rejects these stocks for his own portfolio. They are too risky, offer low returns, and are inconsistent with his value investing strategy. All mentioned stocks have inflated valuations not justified by fundamentals.






