
Should Ethereum Tax Its Apps to Prove Its Security Is Worth It?
This transcript puts a provocative idea on the table: Should Ethereum tax the apps built on it to prove its security is actually worth the cost? The speaker challenges the foundational value propositions of the ETH token.
Challenging the "Store of Value" Thesis- The speaker dismisses Vitalik Buterin's vision of ETH as a Store of Value as a fallacy. Bitcoin is framed as a one-in-a-billion fluke ("immaculate conception"), not a replicable standard. Without assuming the dominance of Ethereum over all other blockchains, the store of value argument for ETH collapses.
- A major critique targets the inability of Ethereum proponents to quantify the value of the token. The fundamental question is asked: How many apps, transactions, or stablecoins need to exist on Ethereum before the token itself gains intrinsic value? Answers allegedly remain vague, focusing on protocol quality rather than token value accrual.
Hyperliquid is highlighted as a successful L1 model because it captures value directly through its native DEX and stablecoin distribution.
- Hindsight Option: Ethereum should have built its own native stablecoin and DEX.
- Current Proposal: Tax the apps. If Ethereum's security is as invaluable as claimed, applications should be willing to pay a tax to use it.
- The Litmus Test: The tax rate determines reality. If apps stay and pay, security is proven. If they migrate to cheaper chains, the security premium is exposed as a commodity.
The proposal serves as a financial litmus test for the value creation of the Ethereum network. It moves the debate from philosophical visions to raw market consent.






